Made For You

With Love

Baking Butters offers southern, down-home desserts all made from scratch with quality ingredients. Our flagship item is brown butter chocolate chip cookies (also available in a delicious sugar-free option). The recipes are crafted from traditional to modern flavored cookies, cakes and pies that are all passed down recipes perfected to ensure everlasting tastes and return customers.

Baking Butters prides itself on old-fashioned baking techniques and recipes. We are sure these flavors will take you back to the good old care-free days!

Our Gallery

Our Favorites

All products made to order, freshly served.  

Cookies (Single Flavor)

Half Dozen $8

Full Dozen $16


Whole  $45

Per Slice   $6

Cookies (Mixed, up to 3 flavors)

Full Dozen $21

Peanut Butter Sheet Cake

Whole   $20

Make your event special with our Cakes

If you have a special order, speak with us.